Of Pinecones, Peacocks, and Popes
The Vatican Museum and St. Peter’s Basilica
I must confess ambivalence about our tours of both the Vatican Museum and St. Peter’s Basilica. The art in both places is magnificent—beyond magnificent, it is breathtaking. As art museums, both spaces are incomparable, and I can enjoy them as such. What each space says not only about the Catholic Church but Christian churches in general and the question of what role they should play in the world, however, is troubling. The amassing of priceless art (as in the Vatican Museum) and the degree to which the Popes have used St. Peter’s primarily as a glorification of themselves is unsettling, even aggravating. While St Peter’s is certainly a church, by almost every measure—weight, volume, coverage, space allocation—it is a temple to the popes. Rick Steves recommends becoming a Catholic for two days in order to appreciate these sites. I found that an almost impossible task. Nevertheless, I am glad to have visited both because they contain some of the most beautiful art we encountered and I have long believed that it is the creative spark within humankind—no matter how grand, no matter how humble—that most closely approximates that which we call God.
The Romans were great copiers of Greek art. In some cases, the reproductions the Romans created are the only record we have of original Greek art because the originals were destroyed. That is the case with this discus thrower.
In fact, according to our group tour guide, most of the statues in this hallway, through which we entered the Vatican Museum, were copies of Greek work.
The statuary hall gave way to the hall of tapestries. The Vatican Museum is evidently overseen by someone with severe OCD. Everything has a place and everything in its place.
Most of the tapestries, naturally, are images from major incidents in the life of Christ and, since they were placed by OCD overseer, they are in chronological order beginning with the nativity . . .
. . . and ending with the resurrection.
Let not your heart be troubled, though. Some were devoted to colleagues in the discipline of Communication Studies. Although there was not a Performance Studies tapestry, there was, in fact, one devoted to Rhetoric.
The Hall of Tapestries gave way to the Gallery of Maps. Pope Gregory XIII hired scads of cartographers and produced a series of highly 40 highly detailed frescoes mapping the entire Italian peninsula. Though produced in the 1580s, they are said to be 80% accurate.
Did I mention that everything was ornate. Everything, including the ceilings.
Frankly, I got enamored when I realized I could reverse my camera and get better pictures of the ceilings without bending over backward. I took lots of pictures of ceilings (including domes).
In addition to religious subjects, the philosophers were well represented. They had their own painting . . .
. . . with Plato and Aristotle presented predominately.
. . . and below.
We had initially hoped to see the Vatican Museum and St. Peter’s Basilica on the same day. By the time we had finished the museum, however, the line to get into the basilica snaked all the way around St. Peter’s square. So, we opted to come back another day when we could arrive at opening. The choice to do so was a good one. We arrived and were inside within 20 minutes.
Of the many things that I wanted to see while in Italy, Michelangelo’s Pieta was at the top of my list. When you walk into the basilica and look to the right, there it is, in all of its glory. It did not disappoint, and I was glad to have seen his second pieta, The Deposition, in Florence. Along with David, these were my favorite pieces.
Although people rave about the magnificence of the Sistine Chapel, I’m going to have to agree with Michelangelo. Although he agreed to paint, first and foremost he considered himself a sculptor. I was thrilled to learn, as I am sure Jenn Aglio will be, that Michelangelo was an old, crotchety, introverted genius who didn’t really care all that much for people. His primary competition was Raphael, who was a young, cute, extrovert. Talented, yes, but does one really need to know how to work a room to prove one’s genius?
Ah, the tombs of the popes. “What would this cathedral be about if it were about me?” seems to be the sentiment of many of the popes. Thus, they erected elaborate tombs for themselves, hiring the greatest sculptors of the day. There are a couple buried here (not sure if they were really a couple).
Three more shared this tomb.
Some of the popes, however, were not content to share their final resting place with their brethren and had elaborate graven images of themselves created to grace their tombs.
I must admit, though, that I loved this one. Not as a tomb, but as art. Although it is a pope tomb, it was carved by the great Bernini. He was responsible for the Elephant Obelisk outside Santa Maria Sopra Minerva church where Galileo was threatened with torture.
Before we leave St. Peter’s, I would like to share my second favorite feature of the basilica. These three works, which appear to be paintings, are, in fact, mosaics. The reason that their colors have remained so vivid after so many years is because of the stone, some precious and semi-precious, that were used in their creation. The craftsmanship of the monks who created these paintings is amazing. Only when you get very near them does it become apparent—if you’re looking for it—that they are composed of tiny stones.
And to conclude, a parting shot.
I am glad we came but, as I said before, I’m ambivalent. (BTW, the opinions shared here are mine alone.)




























No comments:
Post a Comment