Heresy!
Turns out that one person’s science is another institution’s heresy. The Catholic Church had a vested interest in its belief structure remaining intact. Therefore, when scientists offered observations that contradicted canonical law, something had to give. That something often turned out to be the health or life of the scientist in question.
Galileo was charged with heresy by the Church when he proclaimed that Earth was not the center of the universe around which all the heavens revolved but that, in fact, the Earth revolved around the sun. The Church, operating on the “we are, after all, us and the center of our own universe” principle tried Galileo Galilei in the Santa Maria Sopra Minerva (Saint Mary Above Minerva) Church, which is located in the Piazza della Minereva. You see, the Church had been quite successful in crushing the pantheon of Roman gods and had turned their eyes toward the heretical scientists who also had the potential to undermine their authority.
The square in front of the church is dominated by The Elephant and the Obelisk. The Ancient Egyptian obelisk was unearthed in the garden of the church in 1665, and the current pope, Alexander VII wanted it erected outside the church and asked Bernini to design a suitable base. Bernini chose an elephant and designed this striking monument.
Meanwhile, back to Galileo’s heresy trial. It is said that in their attempts to persuade Galileo to recant the heretical notion that Earth was not the center of the universe, his inquisitors took him to the basement to show him the instruments of torture that they would use on him if he persisted in proclaiming this belief. Apparently, Galileo, rather than submitting to torture, agreed to sign whatever papers the Church required. After signing the documents and being set free by his inquisitors, he exited the church. Passing the guards that flanked the door, he leaned over to one and whispered “eppur si muove” (“And yet it moves!”). Galileo and science, in the end, had the last word.
When it comes to heretics, though, Giordano Bruno was the real thing. While he began as a Dominican Friar, he later embraced Calvinism. A scientist, like Galileo, Bruno studied the heavens and declared that the stars visible in the night sky were other suns and that there were innumerable planets that orbited around these suns. Further, if one could travel through space to one of those suns and look back at our solar system, our sun would appear merely as a star. As with Galileo, this didn’t sit well with the Earthnocentric Catholic Church. These observations, though, were the least of his heretical sins. When it comes to heresy, he went all in, denying several core Catholic doctrines, including the idea of eternal damnation, the concept of the Trinity, the divinity of Christ, the virginity of Mary, and transubstantiation. As the British would say, “In for a penny, in for a pound.”
Oddly, he was condemned to burn at the stake because of his scientific views rather than his challenging of Catholic doctrine. In passing sentence, the Roman Inquisition described him as “an impenitent, pertinacious, and obstinate heretic,” to which he replied, “You may be more afraid to bring that sentence against me than I am to accept it.”
In 1600, the Church burned him at the stake in the Campo de’ Fiori (Field of Flowers). A statue erected by the people in the neighborhood, marks the spot of his execution.
Today, the Campo de’ Fiori is the site of a thriving street market with vendors of all sorts, including some of the freshest fruit and vegetables available in the city.






No comments:
Post a Comment