Thursday, July 19, 2018

Lessons in Carols
Medieval Edition

One of my favorite architectural features of Sainte Chapelle is the tile work surrounding the entrance to the upper chapel that is presided over by none other than JC. Like a contemporary lesson in carols, I would like to develop a tour based on these tiles alone, as they tell--sometimes with startling accuracy--both familiar and not-so-familiar stories from the Old Testament. While impossible to give a full preview of my "Tales in Tiles" tour, I thought it might be fun to give you a preview.


This initial tile depicts the patriarchal tale that we have always been taught about the events that transpired in the Garden of Eden. This lesson might suitably be titled, "If not for the woman, we might still reside in the Garden." Note that Eve is already munching down on the apple. Proving, definitively, that she was clearly the instigator of the fall. The tile also shows, however, that she had help, the snake with the human face, presumably the founder of the house of Slytherin, appears to have talked her into taking that first step.  


Adam, however, when confronted by God, completely forgets or deliberately ignores the role of the snake in provoking his disobedience to the Father. Perhaps it is because the snake is no longer in the picture, having beat a hasty retreat. The tree survives but the snake, having slithered away, leaves Eve to take the blame. Adam is only too happy to throw Eve under the Edenic equivalent of the bus, pointing out to God in true patriarchal fashion that "She started it." What was Eve to do? Why protest? After all, at that point in the mythical past, she was outnumbered two to one.


Never being one to do His own dirty work, God left the unpleasant task of expulsion to one of his angels. Adam and Eve, still ashamed of their nakedness as in the last tile, covering it with fig leaves, depart the garden (which is depicted behind the angel with leaves and fruit) at the behest of the angel with his fiery sword. Seems to me that's a lot of fuss over a bite or two of an apple. Perhaps God was looking ahead to the twentieth century and the advent of Steve Jobs mega-conglomerate. Figuring apples would all get us in the end anyway, he figured, "Why wait?" Seems sound.

The tale of Noah also figured prominently among the tiles, two of which are provided here. In my opinion, the significant figure in both these tiles is the building in the background. First, it seems to contradict the Old Testament account, which suggests that the entire world was covered by water.  I'm fairly certain the story does not say the entire world was covered by water except for this one building.

In the first tile, the animals line up in pairs to enter the Ark. (I would note that this tile does not depict the dinosaurs, which according to many inerrantists HAD to be present since the earth is only a bit over 2000 years old and, after all, how are you going to explain dinosaur fossils otherwise.)  Enough digression. Called of God, the animals all found a partner--presumably they were all heterosexual animals--and lined up to enter the big boat.


Now, in the second tile, using the building as a marker--a measure against which we gauge the extent of the flood--we can see that the floodwaters that covered the earth during the great flood were evidently no deeper than an ox (featured in the lower foreground).  


This fact, seems to me to beg the question of why load elephants (depicted) or giraffes (not depicted) into the big boat.  Couldn't they simply hold their trunks, in the case of the former, or necks, in the case of the latter, above the waters until they receded? The exclusion of these large animals, as well as others who might have perched on the ample roof of the building in the back, would have provided additional room whereby Noah could have saved either more humans.  Or, even in the unlikely case that he was a sadistic introvert intent on never having to spend time in a crowded room desperately attempting to avoid small talk, he might have saved another few animals from each species. Perhaps this tile more realistically reflects the world's most fundamental truth: history has largely been written and preserved by men.

Rather than go on and on about the tour, I'll add a few extra tiles that require further reflection and, in doing so, I will provide only my initial thoughts.

In all honesty, I haven't quite worked out which stories these tiles represent. Thus, I will provide only brief story outlines that I might pursue as part of the tour.


In this tile, the figure on the right might be saying, "I really want to offer up this lamb as a sacrifice, but I'm afraid the fire is not hot enough. Could you throw another faggot onto the fire?" In response, the figure on the right appears to be indicating that he thinks the fire is quite hot enough. Turning away and holding his head back so he won't singe his eyebrows or lovely wavy locks, he nevertheless concedes to the wishes of the potential lamb burner.



If anything, this tile is even stranger. The figure on the right, clearly a pacifist since he is holding his weapon in a direction clearly away from his counterpart, merely touches the bag topped by what appears to be a lamb. (Could that, in fact, be a bag full of lambs?) In my estimation, this is the not the first time he has touched the other fellow's bag of lambs--who knows with what intentions. The shovel wielding figure on the right has evidently already swung the shovel once, hitting the first figure in the face and breaking off his nose. Undeterred, and intent on having his way with the other guy's lamb bag, figure one has made another grab for it, provoking yet another swing of the dangerous weapon. I don't remember this particular Bible story, but would be willing to do more research in order to get to the bottom of this most intriguing Old Testament tale.  

I invite my readers, who may be more familiar with these last two stories to weigh in through comments to educate me further as I continue to explore the possibilities for the tour.


3 comments:

  1. Cain and Able - God liked Able's lamb sacrifice better than Caine's wheat sacrifice. So to fix that, Cain killed Able. It was all Eve's fault.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. In church history, I have found that it is almost always the woman's fault! I appreciate the clarification.

      Delete
    2. In light of what you say here, it looks as if another problem with Cain was that he was most definitely NOT a cheerful giver.

      Delete